Articles Tagged with determination of title

underwood-title-determinative-300x300In California, title is determinative in some instances. This means that a court’s characterization of property in a marital dissolution proceeding determines the division of the property between spouses. How a property is titled may also affect the property’s protection from creditors, taxes, and the probate process. Understanding how and when title is determinative is important because married individuals may hold title in various forms affecting their interests in dissolutions. 

What is a Property Title?

A title is not a physical document given to individuals who acquire interest in property. Instead, a property title is a legal concept made up of various documents, like deeds and surveys, that represent various rights inherent in the ownership of real property. It is important to distinguish the difference between a Title and a Deed. Title refers to the concept of legal ownership of property. Oppositely, a deed is the physical document that transfers legal ownership of the property. In short, deeds help establish title. 

A chess board where the king fell down
In many ways, partition actions are relatively straightforward. Generally, in a partition action, the two property owners cannot agree on its use, and one of the owners asks the court to sell the property so each can go their separate ways.

The question arises of whether one of the two persons actually owns the property in the first instance. When there is a question of whether one of the parties is an owner, can you contest the title in a partition action? The answer is “yes,” as one of the primary purposes of a partition action is a determination of title.

Generally, at trial, the court must determine whether the plaintiff has the right to partition. (CCP § 872.210(a).) A question of ownership of property, as presented in a partition action, may be one of fact or law, depending on whether the determination of the issue involves a decision on conflicting facts or the application of the law to a stated set of facts. (Lieb v. Superior Court (1962) 199 Cal.App.2d 364.)

Contact Information